Skip to Content

5 Year old talking back? What our expert has to say!

(Be sure to enter DAILY! $50 giveaway for Constructive Playthings Here)

Q: My five year old has started to talk back to us when we ask him to do something.  We are reasonable with our requests, however he feels the need to talk back when we ask him to do something he doesn’t want.  ~ “Help please”!!!

A:  A five year that talks back…well that is hard to believe (insert sarcasm here).  Well ~ “Help please”!!!, without knowing anymore details it sounds like your five year old is right on par with his development.  It is perfectly normal for a child to start to “test the waters”.  However his future “testing” can be halted if you take the appropriate steps now.
First you cannot let your child get away with this.  If he finds the smallest crack, we will blow it wide open.  Children are very clever and will do what it takes to get what they want.
Consistency, consistency, consistency is the second step.  If the child knows that I say yes after 15 times, well he will do it 15 times, or 30 or 50 times or whatever time you caved.  Eventually the child will give up and you will be the victorious parent.
As I watch my own children I have come to the conclusion that children think the world revolves around them, their rules and their expectations for their world.  Children are very egocentric and will do what it takes to get what they want and it is up to us to remind them that they are children and we are the parent.  We are called to do this in a gentle loving way.  Children are not this way because they want to be difficult.  This is just the way they are and this is how children learn.
Now parents, go forth and teach the next generation.

Do you have a question you would like answered on Q & A with Trevor
E-mail your questions to mommymomentblog AT gmail DOT com with the Title Q & A in the subject line or use our contact form in the top link bar! You can also leave your questions in the comment section here if you prefer!

Amy Walker

Friday 9th of July 2010

Following from the blog hop! Looking forward to reading this!Amy @ www.thecheapandchoosy.blogspot.com

Mrs4444

Friday 9th of July 2010

I agree wholeheartedly with this advice. Children crave limits. Testing those limits is what they do to be reassured that they are not in charge in this great, big scary world.

Another suggestion I have is to have a little talk about it when you are both calm and not in the thick of an argument; maybe during a time that he does accept your direction. You can reinforce that behavior by saying something like this, "Thank you. You're a very good listener. I feel respected when you do what I ask you to do."

Missy

Friday 9th of July 2010

Great answer! And so true - consistency is the key.