Skip to Content

The Rule Keeper

Sometimes it feels like a burden, this insistence I have on following the rules.  Sometimes it feels like maybe my kids are missing out.  Like I’m interfering with their natural inclinations to play without restraint.

Up the ladder, down the slide.

Let’s keep the sand in the sandbox.

Let’s sit on the bouncer, just to be safe.

Everybody needs a turn…

At times, it’s lonely out there.  Every once in a while I meet another rule keeper, but, for the most part, it’s just me.

These days, they don’t need many reminders.  The rules, it seems, are understood.

You can climb up the slide at home, but at the park we just slide down.

Inevitably, they are up against kids who play without rules or limits.  Kid who don’t feel compelled to give someone else a turn.  Kids who climb up the slide every time, preventing the others from sliding down.  Kids who pelt one another with tennis balls and take toys without asking.  Kids who take sand from the sandbox and pour it all over the concrete…creating a significant safety hazard.

Always, when we are up against these kids, someone gets hurt.

Once it was my three year old boy who slipped on the sand hazard and cut his lip open.  One month later, the scar has yet to heal.

Often, it’s the very kids in question.  The kids whose parents are nowhere to be found.  The kids whose parents look the other way so that they can take a break.

Just the other day, a young woman brought two little boys to the park.  We exchanged smiles and quick hellos, but the four year old had her on the run.  He wasn’t listening, he wasn’t following directions, and he wasn’t being safe.  Every time the young woman turned to interact with the older child, the little one made a dangerous move.  She tried to stop him.  She told him that feared he would fall.  She told him that she wanted him to be safe.  “I understand that mom and dad let you do this, but when you’re with Auntie we have to play safe.”

Poor Auntie didn’t stand a chance.  This little boy was determined to climb up the outside of the tunnel slide.  A very, very large tunnel slide.  She was powerless to stop him.  Sure enough, he fell a great distance.  His bones remained in tact, it seems, but his left ear had a giant scrape right down the middle.  The bleeding was instant.  The screaming was too.  The poor little boy finally took a break.

In that moment, I was reminded that being the rule keeper isn’t so bad after all.  I might not be able to prevent injuries, but I know that I can trust my kids to make good choices.  I know that they will climb up the stairs, slide down the slide, and make sure other kids get a turn.  I know that they will keep the sand in the sandbox and watch out for others when swinging.  I know that they will follow the rules.

And the truth is that my kids do play without restraint.

Every single day.

Are you a rule keeper too?

Katie is a Child & Adolescent Psychotherapist/Parenting Expert in Los Angeles, CA.  She has a five year old daughter, three year old son, and a rock and roll husband who makes her life complete. Katie has a parenting advice blog, Practical Parenting, and can be found on Twitter.  She also writes for moonfrye.

Julia @AskMamaMOE

Sunday 26th of February 2012

Love this post! I too am a rule keeper. My DH is more laid back and something we butt heads, but mostly it's in the situations you described with other mamas. Park play or even playgroups can end up to be exhausting if you are the only parent on guard. Thanks for such an honest post - I will be sharing it promptly! :)

The Marx family rocks

Saturday 25th of February 2012

Great piece. It's so true and it's wonderful to hear another mom admitting that rues are there for a reason. Not so mom and dad can be strict because they enjoy it. More so for us to give you boundaries which make you feel as safe and happy as we can. Your blog came at just the right time for me. A friend of mines child is now putting my son at risk with her behaviour and it is really scaring me. I can put the rules out there for my son to follow, but I am struggeling to protect him from her ever increasing dangerous play. She has no boundaries and will do anything for attention. It leaves me baffled. Reading your post makes me realize I need to just stick with my approach and it will continue to pay dividends in the long run. Thank you, your words made my weekend.

Pamela

Thursday 23rd of February 2012

I'm a rule keeper; which in these days is sometimes equated with helicopter parenting. I have a hard time with folks who can't make the distinction between responsible parenting and hovering and I've written on the topic of both playground etiquette and the "helicopter" phenomenon myself. My daughter is extremely independent, given many age appropriate choices, and can do many things that other children her age haven't been given an opportunity to try. We let her struggle and learn. But when it comes to physical safety, respect for others and for property, and minding us, we are pretty strict and involved. Parents need to learn how to differentiate giving freedom to their kids from letting their kids be wild and out of control to the detriment of their safety and of others. Kids need space, but they also need boundaries and limits. Thoughtful post!

Practical Parenting

Friday 24th of February 2012

Thank you. I agree, certain boundaries are necessary. It teaches them to look out for others in the world...isn't that something we all strive to teach our kids? Thanks for your comment.

Tragic Sandwich

Thursday 23rd of February 2012

I want to teach Baguette to share the world, and rules are part of how we do that. At the same time, I think it's important to remember that different people have different rules, as Angela points out--that's a valuable lesson to learn, too.

So other kids at the playground aren't following your rules--that doesn't mean that they have none to follow. Maybe that's the case. Or maybe their parents have different rules (some of which may not be priorities for you).

Practical Parenting

Friday 24th of February 2012

I totally agree that all families have different rules. It's when kids are making really unsafe choices and putting other kids in harms way that I get upset about it. There should be certain safety standards when playing in large groups...

Kim Rempel

Thursday 23rd of February 2012

Exactly! Rules = freedom, even if it doesn't look that way at first. Well put.

Practical Parenting

Friday 24th of February 2012

Yes, I like that! Freedom :)